top of page

Let's Talk


Our privacy promise: We will not sell / use your contact information outside our agency.

Hourly Rates Are Unethical: What Fee Structure is Best For Client and Private Investigator

coins falling from a jar. Value-based fees private investigator
Hourly rate billing is unethical. We have heard every excuse, including "but each project is so different". The reality, it isn't and private investigators need to bring the consumer more value.

Introduction To Hourly Rates Are Unethical

In the world of professional private investigation services, billing practices significantly influence client relationships and business reputation. Traditionally, hourly billing has been the norm, but we argue that this method is unethical. Instead, we advocate for value-based fees, a pricing strategy that aligns more closely with client interests and ethical business practices. In this article, we'll delve into why hourly billing is unethical and how value-based fees offer a more honest and effective way to serve clients.

The Pitfalls of Hourly Billing

Incentivizes Longer Hours, Not Efficient Work

Hourly billing creates an inherent conflict of interest between the private investigator and the client. It rewards private investigators for spending more time on a task, regardless of the outcome or efficiency. This model can lead to unnecessarily prolonged projects, driving up costs for the client without adding real value.

Hourly rates are bad for both of us. If I work longer and inefficiently

Lack of Transparency and Predictability

Clients often feel in the dark about the final cost when charged by the hour. This lack of transparency can lead to unexpected expenses and erodes trust. Clients prefer knowing the cost upfront, which hourly billing rarely provides.

Misalignment of Interests

With hourly billing, the focus shifts from the client's desired outcome to the number of hours logged. You've seen this with just about every professional service imaginable, and law firms, accountants and private investigators are just a few. This misalignment can lead to a deterioration in the quality of work, as the primary goal becomes billing hours rather than achieving results.

Should you pay a private investigator for how many hours they work, or the value they bring to the project?

The Honesty of Value-Based Fees

Aligns Interests of Client and Provider

Value-based fees tie the cost of services to the value delivered, not the time spent. This approach aligns the private investigation agency incentives with the client's goals, fostering a partnership-oriented relationship.

Promotes Efficiency and Innovation

Since the fee is not tied to hours worked, investigators are motivated to work more efficiently and innovatively. This efficiency not only benefits the client but also allows the investigation firm to take on more projects and increase their earning potential.

Enhances Transparency and Trust

Value-based pricing is agreed upon in advance, providing clarity and predictability for the client. This transparency builds trust and can lead to long-term client relationships. Who wants to pay for an unknown?

Case Studies and Real-World Examples

Law Firms Embracing Change

Some progressive law firms have shifted to value-based billing, reporting higher client satisfaction and better case outcomes. Clients appreciate the clarity in costs and the focus on results rather than billable hours.

Marketing Agencies Leading the Way

Marketing agencies, known for their creative and results-driven work, often use value-based pricing. This model allows them to tailor their services to the specific needs and goals of each client, resulting in more successful campaigns.

Private Investigators Getting On Board?

Actually, out of about 300 private investigation firms we have looked at, none talk about value-based fees. In fact, most offer no indication of hourly pricing either. Makes you wonder doesn't it?

We decided to lead the charge among private investigators. We have offer flat rate pricing based on the value of the project for more than 3 years now.

The Ethical Implications

Fairness and Honesty in Business Practices

Value-based fees are inherently more ethical because they ensure that clients only pay for the real value received. This approach fosters a culture of fairness and honesty, essential in any professional relationship.

The Client’s Best Interest at Heart

By focusing on the client’s desired outcome rather than hours billed, professionals are more likely to act in the best interest of their clients, adhering to higher ethical standards.

How Can A Private Investigator Introduce Value-Based Fees

Private investigators can adopt various value-based fee structures that align more closely with the outcomes and value they provide to their clients, rather than simply charging by the hour. Here are some examples of value-based fees that a private investigator might charge for:

Fixed-Price for Specific Services:

A set fee for a specific service such as background checks, locating a person, or conducting surveillance for a predetermined period. This fee is agreed upon in advance, providing clarity and predictability for the client.

Success-Based Fees:

Fees that are contingent on achieving specific results. For example, a higher fee might be charged if the investigator is successful in finding substantial evidence in a case or locating a missing person. This aligns the investigator's incentives with the client's goals.

Tiered Pricing Based on Complexity:

Different pricing tiers for cases of varying complexity. Simple cases like basic background checks might have a lower fee, while more complex investigations involving extensive surveillance or international inquiries would have higher fees.

Retainer for Ongoing Services:

For clients who need ongoing investigative services, such as businesses conducting regular background checks or continuous surveillance, a monthly or annual retainer fee can be arranged. This provides the client with predictable costs and ensures the investigator is available when needed.

Package Deals for Multiple Services:

Offering packages that bundle several services together for a single price. For instance, a package might include a background check, asset search, and a certain amount of surveillance work.

Consultation and Advisory Fees:

Charging for providing expert advice and consultancy, especially in complex legal cases, corporate investigations, or security matters. This is particularly relevant for investigators with specialized expertise.

Performance Milestones:

Setting fees based on achieving certain milestones in an investigation. For example, one fee could be set for gathering preliminary information, another for obtaining concrete evidence, and a final fee for completing the report.

Customized Solutions:

Developing a custom fee structure based on the unique needs and objectives of the client. This could involve a combination of the above methods tailored to the specific requirements of the case.

In all these models, the key is to clearly define the value being provided and ensure that the fee structure aligns with the client's objectives and expectations. This approach fosters trust and transparency, leading to more satisfactory client relationships.


In conclusion, while hourly billing has been a longstanding practice for private investigators, it poses several ethical concerns, primarily related to misaligned interests, lack of transparency, and inefficiency.

In contrast, value-based fees offer a more honest, transparent, and client-focused approach. This fee structure benefits clients but also encourages other private investigation professionals to work more efficiently and innovatively, leading to better outcomes and more sustainable business relationships with the consumer, law firms and business clients.. As the professional world evolves, the shift towards value-based fees seems not only ethical but also essential for future growth and client satisfaction.


bottom of page